Loading...
Risk Assessment generated by a regulatory process (RA)
  |  
BCH-RA-NL-104438-2   |   PDF   |   Print   |  
| 
last updated: 28 Nov 2012
General Information
Potato late blight control strategies and monitoring of Phytophthora infestans virulence.
EN
28 Feb 2011
Risk assessment details
  • Potato resistant to Phytophthora infestans
    | Resistance to antibiotics (Kanamycin), Resistance to diseases and pests (Phytophthora infestans resistance)
Methodology and points to consider
One potential effect may be an increased selective advantage in natural environments due to the insertion of the late blight resistance genes. Potato cultivars, produced through classical breeding methods, containing late blight resistance genes (Rpi-genes) have been cultivated for several decades without any negative impact on the environment or human health.
EN
The release concerns field trials with a maximum plot size of 1 hectare per site with an annual maximum of 5 sites. Given the biology of potato and the nature of the used resistance genes, no specific measures to confine any potential effects are considered to be necessary, other than the regular good practice already in place for commercial potato cultivation.
EN
EN
The risk on any adverse effect is considered to be negligible.
EN
Standard good agricultural practices will be applied. This means that an isolation distance of 3 m to other potato fileds will be observed. Planting and harvesting equipment will be cleaned on site to prevent the dispersal of GM tubers. There will be no potato cultivation on the release area for the year following the release. Potential volunteers will be monitored and removed according to conventionel agricultural practice. During the release the trial site will be monitored at defined intervals.
EN
EN
The field trials will be conducted various parts of the Netherlands. Under Dutch climatic conditions potato is biologically contained. Commercial cultivation of potatoes occurs also in these regions.
EN
No specific validated detection method are available (yet).
EN
Additional information
The genetically modified potato lines contain a maximum of three different two Rpi-genes from S. bulbocastanum and other related Solanum species conferring improved resistance to P. infestans. The Rpi-genes belong to the class of NbARC-LRR genes(also known as NBS-LRR genes). Many conventional potato varieties also contain additional NbARC-LRR-genes that have been introgressed from wild Solanum species. An intended effect of the introduced trait is an increased survivability in potato fields exposed to P. infestans. This possible selective advantage, however, is of importance only in the agricultural field, and will not improve the survivability in the surrounding environment. The reduced need for fungicides on these lines can easily be identified as an environmental benefit.
No difference with respect to persistence in agriculturally utilised habitats or invasiveness into natural habitats as compared to conventional potato varieties is expected. Through the measures which are taken during the release, distance from or absence of conventionally cultivated potatoes or wild species, the possibility of any gene transfer can be virtually ruled out. Even in the very improbable event that pollen were to be transferred to genetically unmodified potato plants, no consequences are to be expected, since potato propagation conventionally takes place via tubers and not via seeds. The interactions of the genetically modified potato line with non-target organisms and the effects resulting from this will be comparable to those with conventional potato varieties. Furthermore, no toxic or allergenic effects are expected on the basis of the improved resistance to P. infestans. No effects on biogeochemical processes are expected, other than those that apply also to conventional potatoes.

The purpose of the experiments is twofold:
1) Mixtures of true to type, resistant (R) and susceptible (S) plants are studied as a model for R/R mixtures after break through of one of the Rpi-genes or Rpi-gene cassettes. The purpose is to establish relationships between the mixing ratio of resistant/susceptible and the resulting (beneficial) spatial and temporal delay of epidemic progress. The results give insight in the added value of- and ideal composition of true to type dynamic cultivars and the most durable way to deploy them in time and space.
2) Monitoring of the P. infestans population for adaptation (virulence) to newly introduced Rpi-genes and Rpi-gene cassettes. This information is crucial for strategies for durable deployment of Rpi genes.
EN